Grumpy Old Santa – Film Review

Published September 25, 2023

Movie Details

Rating
B-
Director
Jay Dee Walters
Writer
Jay Dee Walters, Justin Chaffee
Actors
Glenn Morshower, Kevin Farley, Gary Valentine, Micah Lyons, Dodie Brown
Runtime
1 h 23 min
Release Date
September 12, 2023
Genres
Comedy, Drama, Family, Romance
Certification

In his new comedy Grumpy Old Santa, director Jay Dee Walters tries to strike a balance between heartwarming drama and hilarious humor. The film, which stars Glenn Morshower as Nic, a devoted family man who must navigate the perilous waters of dating after his wife leaves, has funny and endearing moments. Overall, though, it receives a mixed response because it also stumbles in some places.

Nic, a middle-aged man who appears to have it all—a loving family, a passion for fishing and bowling, and a close-knit group of friends—is introduced to us at the beginning of the narrative. Nic’s life, however, is completely upended when his wife leaves him after their kids have left the nest. As we watch Nic struggle with loneliness and heartache, this preamble creates a compelling premise. Glenn Morshower gives a commendable performance, giving his character’s emotional journey depth and authenticity.

The story’s examination of the difficulties of dating and relationships in middle age is one of its strongest features. The narrative gains comedic tension from Nic’s choice to date Pastor Kris’s (Kevin Farley) sister covertly. A standout of the film is Kevin Farley’s portrayal of Pastor Kris, a well-intentioned but overbearing friend. Every scene Farley is in is made funnier by his comedic timing and outrageous antics, which are responsible for many of the film’s hilarious moments.

Additionally, Grumpy Old Santa does a fantastic job of encapsulating small-town life, especially in the scenes at the neighborhood bowling alley and fishing hole. A lot of the humor is set in these locations, which also give the audience a sense of comfort and nostalgia. The interactions between Nic and his friends from fishing and bowling are both endearing and funny, demonstrating the ability of friendship to mend broken hearts and offer much-needed comic relief.

The comedy here is generally done well, and there are some truly funny parts in the script. It does, however, occasionally rely on cliched jokes and formulaic jokes, which can get old. While the humor is generally lighthearted, it does occasionally veer into the slapstick category, which may not be to everyone’s taste. A few scenes may feel forced or out of place within the overall story, which may cause some viewers to find the humor uneven.

The film really shines in its heartwarming areas. Nic starts to rediscover his own identity and the value of self-love as he works through the difficulties of dating. The message, which emphasizes embracing change and finding happiness in unexpected places, is heartfelt and universal.

Grumpy Old Santa has some serious shortcomings despite its many positive aspects. Its pacing can feel off at times; some scenes drag on while others move quickly through crucial character arcs. In some cases, the film introduces subplots that aren’t adequately resolved, leaving open ends that could have been better closed.

Predictability in the film is another problem. The story’s direction is obvious as soon as Nic begins dating his best friend’s sister, and the plot develops in a fairly formulaic way from that point on. While the plot of romantic comedies is frequently predictable, Grumpy Old Santa might have benefited from a few more unexpected turns.

The production values are passable; the cinematography is adequate, and the musical score is appropriate, if a little forgettable. Although Jay Dee Walters’ direction is competent, the movie lacks a clear visual identity. Grumpy Old Santa comes off as a predictable and safe comedy-drama due to its lack of visual flair.

Nic’s transformation throughout the length of the film is well-done in terms of character development, but some of the supporting characters are still flat. For example, Nic’s children feel underdeveloped and lack emotional depth, which reduces our emotional investment in their supporting stories. A notable flaw is the fact that the chance to examine how Nic’s divorce affected his family members was lost.

Grumpy Old Santa has a few heartwarmingly charming and humorous moments. Strong performances are given by Glenn Morshower and Kevin Farley, and the film does a good job of examining the difficulties of dating and falling in love in middle age. It doesn’t quite live up to its potential due to shortcomings in originality, pacing, and character development. Grumpy Old Santa might be enjoyable if you’re in the mood for a lighthearted comedy with a comforting message, but don’t anticipate it to innovate the genre.