First Cow – Film Review

Two travellers, on the run from a band of vengeful hunters in the 1820s Northwest, dream of striking it rich — but their tenuous plan to make their fortune on the frontier comes to rely on the secret use of a landowner’s prized dairy cow.

In a cinematic landscape often dominated by grandiose blockbusters and high-octane action films, Kelly Reichardt‘s First Cow stands as a gentle yet profound cinematic experience, quietly commanding attention with its understated storytelling and meticulous attention to detail. Set in the early 19th century American Pacific Northwest, this film transports viewers to a simpler time, where the struggle for survival and the pursuit of dreams intertwine in a poignant tale of friendship and ambition.

Reichardt’s directorial finesse is immediately evident from the opening frames of First Cow. The film’s deliberate pacing and meditative cinematography establish a tranquil atmosphere that allows the audience to immerse themselves fully in the narrative. The pristine landscapes, captured by the skilled eye of cinematographer Christopher Blauvelt, evoke a sense of awe and reverence for the untouched wilderness, serving as a metaphorical backdrop for the characters’ aspirations and desires.

The heart of the film lies in the exceptional performances by its cast. John Magaro delivers a compelling portrayal of Otis “Cookie” Figowitz, a gentle and soft-spoken cook with dreams of owning a bakery. Magaro’s nuanced performance brings Cookie to life, imbuing him with a quiet determination that is both endearing and relatable. Opposite him, Orion Lee shines as King-Lu, a Chinese immigrant with a shrewd mind and an adventurous spirit. Lee’s charisma and the chemistry he shares with Magaro create an authentic and emotionally resonant bond between the two characters.

Reichardt’s screenplay, co-written with Jonathan Raymond, is a masterclass in subtlety and character development. The narrative unfolds gradually, drawing viewers into the lives of Cookie and King-Lu as they embark on an ambitious and risky business venture. While the plot may seem deceptively simple, it is in the film’s meticulous attention to detail and the exploration of themes such as friendship, capitalism, and the pursuit of the American Dream that First Cow truly shines.

One of the film’s most remarkable achievements is its ability to capture the essence of the time period it portrays. From the costumes to the production design, every element feels authentic and meticulously researched. Reichardt’s dedication to historical accuracy is evident in the depiction of the harsh realities of frontier life, as well as the social dynamics and racial tensions that permeated the era. Yet, it is in her subtle subversion of these historical norms that the film truly distinguishes itself, challenging viewers to question the established narratives of the past.

The film’s quiet moments are where its power truly lies. Reichardt’s masterful direction allows the characters’ emotions to speak through their actions, as opposed to explicit dialogue. The relationship between Cookie and King-Lu unfolds in a series of stolen glances and shared secrets, painting a portrait of friendship that is tender and profound. These delicate moments of connection between the characters resonate long after the credits roll, a testament to Reichardt’s ability to craft deeply human stories.

First Cow is not without its flaws, however. Some viewers may find the deliberate pacing and lack of conventional plot development to be a hindrance, and those seeking a fast-paced, action-packed film may find themselves disappointed. Yet, it is precisely in its deliberate restraint that the film finds its strength. By eschewing unnecessary embellishments, Reichardt allows the story and characters to breathe, resulting in a more immersive and emotionally resonant experience.

The film’s visual and auditory aesthetics further contribute to its overall impact. The score, composed by William Tyler, perfectly complements the tranquil mood of the film, creating an ethereal soundscape that underscores the characters’ journey. The restrained color palette and natural lighting further enhance the film’s sense of time and place, emphasizing the beauty and simplicity of the Pacific Northwest landscape.

Kelly Reichardt’s First Cow is a quietly powerful film that showcases her exceptional talent as a director and storyteller. Through its meticulous attention to detail, understated performances, and thought-provoking themes, the film offers a compelling exploration of friendship, ambition, and the untamed wilderness of early America. While it may not cater to every viewer’s taste, those who appreciate a slow-burning, introspective experience will find themselves richly rewarded. First Cow is a testament to the enduring power of independent cinema and a shining example of the artistry that can be achieved when filmmakers embrace restraint and nuance.