A Haunting in Venice – Film Review

Published September 13, 2023

Movie Details

Rating
B+
Director
Kenneth Branagh
Writer
Michael Green
Actors
Kenneth Branagh, Kyle Allen, Camille Cottin, Jamie Dornan, Tina Fey
Runtime
1 h 44 min
Release Date
September 13, 2023
Genres
Drama, Mystery, Crime
Certification
PG-13

Celebrated sleuth Hercule Poirot, now retired and living in self-imposed exile in Venice, reluctantly attends a Halloween séance at a decaying, haunted palazzo. When one of the guests is murdered, the detective is thrust into a sinister world of shadows and secrets.

Both admirers and detractors have had mixed reactions to Kenneth Branagh‘s portrayal of Hercule Poirot, the renowned Belgian detective from Agatha Christie. Branagh plays the same character in A Haunting in Venice for the third time, having previously appeared in Murder on the Orient Express (2017) and Death on the Nile (2022). This time, Poirot is sucked into a terrifying and enigmatic story set against the macabre Halloween backdrop of Venice. Branagh gives a strong performance, and the film is visually appealing, but its convoluted plot and excessive cast make it difficult to keep viewers interested throughout the entire running time. But, that’s not to say the film is bad. It’s far from that, actually.

In the film, the retired Poirot, who is now exiled in Venice, is forced to attend a Halloween séance at a dilapidated and haunted palazzo. This scene immediately creates a gloomy, atmospheric tone that prepares the reader for the story’s development. The guests are introduced as the séance gets underway, each with their own secrets and peculiarities. The characters of Kyle Allen as Maxime Gerard, Camille Cottin as the mysterious Russian woman Olga Seminoff, Jamie Dornan as the troubled psychiatrist Dr. Leslie Ferrier, and Tina Fey as Ariadne Oliver, a friend of Hercule Poirot, are all front and center.

The biggest highlight of the film is Branagh as Poirot. His portrayal of the detective captures the essence of Christie’s character by being endearing and enigmatic at the same time. It is clear that Poirot pays close attention to every little detail, has impeccable taste in clothing, and has a distinctive mustache. Branagh’s performance, which features an elegant Belgian accent and razor-sharp wit, is proof of his dedication to the part.

The visual presentation of the film is another primary strength. Venice provides a stunning and eerie setting for the mystery’s development. With its winding canals, dilapidated palazzos, and dimly lit alleyways, cinematographer Haris Zambarloukos masterfully captures the city’s distinctive atmosphere. The teams responsible for production design, costume design, and makeup should be commended for their efforts in building an enthralling world. The film is an excellent option for a Halloween-themed thriller because it makes effective use of decorations and ominous lighting.

Overall, the cast is strong, with each actor giving strong performances. Maxime Gerard is portrayed by Kyle Allen in a particularly intriguing way because he exudes a sense of mystery that keeps the audience in the dark about his true motivations. Olga Seminoff is portrayed by Camille Cottin with a sense of elegance and intrigue, and there is a clear chemistry between her and Kenneth Branagh’s Poirot. Dr. Leslie Ferrier is portrayed by Jamie Dornan as a brooding and complex character, and Ariadne Oliver is played by Tina Fey with a dash of humor and eccentricity.

The film also delves deeper themes like guilt, atonement, and the effects of one’s actions. In the midst of the mystery, these themes give the characters more nuance and offer some thought-provoking moments. These components, though, could have been explored in greater detail to improve the story as a whole because they are not fully developed.

The execution of the narrative is where A Haunting in Venice falls short. As more motives and secrets are revealed, the plot of the movie becomes more complicated. It’s hard to keep track of who’s who and what they’re up to because there are so many characters, each with their own subplot. Christie’s mysteries are known for their complexity, but the film struggles to strike the right balance between mystery and confusion. As a result, some viewers might become disoriented by the convoluted story and unable to fully engage with the mystery.

Additionally, the pacing is off, with long stretches of gradual buildup broken up by quick bursts of action and revelation. The audience’s patience is occasionally tried by the slow-burning tension, which although effective in evoking a sense of unease occasionally feels drawn out. Some viewers might find themselves desiring a more condensed and narrowly focused story.

A Haunting in Venice does make reference to Death on the Nile’s events, especially Poirot’s emotional state. These connections, though, are more tenuous and have little bearing on the story of the latest film.

In addition to Kenneth Branagh’s admirable portrayal of Hercule Poirot, A Haunting in Venice offers a visually stunning experience with an eerie and atmospheric backdrop. Even with its flaws, it still succeeds in giving fans of the genre an engaging and fashionable mystery. It’s worth watching for Branagh’s portrayal of the renowned detective and the atmospheric depiction of Venice, if you can look past its narrative shortcomings.